The Pitch on Butler
Chex & Nut Mix
$3.50
Fresh Cut Fries
$4.50
Smithwick's gravy +3 | Guinness cheese sauce +4
Bacon-Wrapped Sage Apple Scotch Egg
$8.00
Soft boiled, smothered in homemade sausage, wrapped in bacon and baked to perfection. Served w/ choice of tangy dijon, HP sauce, or syrup
Garlic Parm | Whiskey BBQ | Buffalo | Dry Rub | Pitchin Sink
$10.00
served w/ranch or bleu cheese
2 Vegan Cheez option
$9.00
Roasted Brussel Sprouts
$8.00
served w/vegan mustard sauce
Lemon Garlic Roasted Hummus
$8.00
served w/pita chips, celery, and carrot sticks
Soft Pretzels
$5.50
Choice of Smithwick's gravy or Guinness cheese sauce
Sauce Options
$11.00
Whiskey BBQ | Buffalo | Pitchin Sink | Honey Mustard | Ranch | Bleu Cheese | Dijon | Vegan Dijon; add fresh cut fries +3 $11.00
Meech's Homemade Pound Cake
$9.00
Topped w/cinnamon, whipped cream & strawberries
Mixed Green Salad
$9.00
Mixed greens, assorted veggies, french fries, cheddar cheese served w/ranch, bleu cheese, or red wine dijon vinaigrette | add grilled/fried/buffalo chicken +6
Tuna Melt
$13.00
Homemade tuna salad baked w/cheddar and provolone cheese, served on Italian toast w/fresh cut fries
Fresh cheddar mac baked with a panko crust
$13.00
add bacon +1 | Make it Vegan +2 | add grilled/fried/buffalo chicken +3
Banger Sandwich
$15.00
Parma sausage on a toasted roll slathered in bacon onion jam and a dijon sauce, served w/ fresh cut fries
(Make it Vegan!)
$15.00
Foghorn
$15.00
Fried chicken sandwich or wrap, bacon, layered w/tomato, lettuce, cheddar cheese and honey mustard, served w/ fresh cut fries
Homemade Meatloaf Melt
$15.00
Open faced and smothered with Smithwick's gravy, served w/ fresh cut fries
Grilled Chicken Sandwich or Wrap
$14.00
Garlic rosemary chicken, layered w/ tomato, mixed greens and homemade ranch, served w/ fresh cut fries
Mediterranean Chickpea Sandwich or Wrap
$13.00
Roasted chickpeas, arugula, tomato, hummus & dijon vinaigrette, served w/fresh cut fries.
Bangers & Mash
$15.00
Parma sausages atop homemade mashed potatoes smothered in Smithwick's gravy & served w/brussels sprouts
Fish & Chips or Fish Sandwich
$15.00
In-house breaded Haddock served w/ fresh cut fries and a side of tartar
Kaiser roll w/ special sauce and served w/ fresh cut fries
$12.00
add bacon +2 | add sausage +3
Breakfast Bread Pudding
$12.00
Savory bread pudding w/ bacon, cheese, and spinach
French Toast
$13.00
French brioche topped with raspberry, powdered sugar, cinnamon whipped cream & maple syrup
Eggs & Toast w/Bacon or Bangers
$13.00
Eggs cooked to order with toast, home fries, and choice of bacon or sausage
Pitch Cakes w/Bacon or Bangers
$13.00
Meech's famous pancakes served with cinnamon whipped cream, syrup, and choice of bacon or sausage
The Breakfast Bhoy
$16.00
A hybrid of our smashburger w/ bacon and Egg & cheese sandwich. This Bhoy packs a real punch! Served w/ fresh cut fries.
Menu as captured Sep 2, 2026 · source ↗
We hold 230 venues in Pittsburgh, PA and could score 28 of them. This one is not among them, so it has no position — not a low one.
There is no score breakdown to show: nothing we read about this venue earned points in any of the four categories, so a bar chart of zeroes would look like a verdict on the kitchen rather than on what it publishes. What we did read is below.
v1.7.4 0.0/100 = sourcing 0.0/50 (named-farm 0 distinct, named-region 0 distinct, attribute 0 distinct, buzzword 0 distinct) + farm partners 0.0/20 (none scored) + registry 0.0/12 (none listed) + press 0.0/18 (capped at 35% of the 0.0-point evidence base).
Buzzwords only. This venue uses sourcing language ("farm-fresh", "locally sourced") but names no farms, regions, or verifiable attributes.
Coverage
- Best of Pittsburgh 2025 — Best Bar to Day Drink ↗
Pittsburgh City Paper
Press