The Old Fashioned
, Cod
17.95
, Perch
17.95
, Combo Platter
19.95
Poor Man's Lobster - Flakey Alaskan Cod baked with butter and paprika
17.95
Menu as captured Sep 1, 2026 · source ↗
We hold 83 venues in Madison, WI and could score 17 of them. Positions are counted against those 17.
v1.7.4 13.5/100 = sourcing 13.0/50 (named-farm 2 distinct [unresolved (data error — see venue flags), west-allis-wells-farm (producer (unevidenced -> unknown)/None) x0.36], named-region 2 distinct, attribute 4 distinct [class=certification-word x1.00, class=feed-or-husbandry x0.50, class=graded-spec x0.00, class=species-name x0.00], buzzword 0 distinct) + farm partners 0.0/20 (none scored) + registry 0.0/12 (none listed) + press 0.5/18. DATA ERROR: PARTIALLY UNLINKED: 1 named-farm signal(s) with no venue_farms.signal_id citation — scored at the neutral 0.6 weight: Wells Farm
farm
West Allis Wells Farm
Named farm“onions, Bavaria Kitchen's hickory smoked bacon and smoked paprika sauce on a buttered and toasted Classic hard roll from Grebe's Bakery in West Allis Wells Farm Patty Melt 13.95 Featuring locally raised beef from Wells Farm in Rio, WI. Grilled rye bread, caramelized onion, beef”
on the menu · source ↗
Wells Farm
Named farm“a buttered and toasted Classic hard roll from Grebe's Bakery in West Allis Wells Farm Patty Melt 13.95 Featuring locally raised beef from Wells Farm in Rio, WI. Grilled rye bread, caramelized onion, beef patty, Swiss cheese and special sauce. Beef Tenderloin Sandwich 18.95”
on the menu · source ↗
sourcing
Wisconsin cheddar
Named region“Door County cherry-mustard sauce, German potato salad, braised caraway cabbage. Mac & Cheese 12.95 Creamy, rich and of course oozing with Wisconsin Cheddar & Parmesan cheeses Hickory Smoked Bacon Mac & Cheese 14.95 Original Mac & Cheese with Bavaria Kitchen's hickory smoked”
on the menu · source ↗
pasture raised
Attribute“Brunch - Available Saturdays 9-1 Steak and Eggs 23.95 Wood-grilled 8 oz. local pasture raised New York Strip* steak, served with rosemary potatoes, country toast, and two sunny side up eggs* Corned Beef Hash and Eggs”
on the menu · source ↗
organic
Attribute“brat - 9.95 Vegetable Sandwich 11.95 Grilled eggplant, portabella mushroom, wood roasted red pepper and zucchini with LaClare Farms organic goat cheese and black olive tapenade on toasted country bread. Albacore White Tuna Salad Sandwich 12.95 Tuna Salad with roasted”
on the menu · source ↗
seafood
Norwegian salmon
Named region“Grilled Salmon Salad 14.95 Grilled Norwegian salmon with Bavaria Kitchen's hickory smoked bacon, cucumber, shaved red onion, deviled egg, mixed greens with a tarragon”
on the menu · source ↗
protein
Prime
Attribute“to order Dipping Sauces 0.50 Smoked Spanish paprika, roasted garlic, buttermilk ranch, tiger or tiger blue Entrees 8 oz. Center Cut Prime Beef Tenderloin Steak 42.95 Pan-seared beef tenderloin*, nightly potato, honey-thyme roasted carrots, Korbel brandy mushroom cream”
on the menu · source ↗
Prime Rib
Attribute“Saturday Night Prime Rib 39.95-48.95 Slow roasted prime rib served with mashed potatoes, honey-thyme roasted carrots, Texas toast, beef jus and tiger”
on the menu · source ↗
See the week▾
| Sunday | Closed |
|---|---|
| Monday | 11am – 9pm |
| Tuesday | 11am – 9pm |
| Wednesday | 11am – 9pm |
| Thursday | 11am – 9pm |
| Friday | 11am – 10pm |
| Saturday | 9am – 10pm |
Hours checked Aug 31, 2026 · source ↗ · these hours were read from the page text rather than published schedule data, so we show the week instead of calling it open or closed · Always worth confirming with the restaurant.
Coverage
- The Infatuation: Best Restaurants in Madison (updated 2026-06) restaurant guide entry: The Old Fashioned ↗
The Infatuation: Best Restaurants in Madison (updated 2026-06)
Press