Sarge's Delicatessen
jewish-deli
HOT BRISKET OF BEEF SANDWICH
26.95
TONGUE SANDWICH
28.95
TURKEY PASTRAMI SANDWICH
24.95
BOILED HAM SANDWICH
20.95
CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH
19.95
CHOPPED LIVER SANDWICH
22.95
EGG SALAD SANDWICH
17.95
HARD SALAMI SANDWICH
22.95
LIVERWURST SANDWICH
17.95
ROLLED BEEF SANDWICH
27.95
SALAMI SANDWICH
22.95
SHRIMP SALAD SANDWICH
21.95
TUNA SALAD SANDWICH
18.95
WHITEFISH SALAD SANDWICH
21.95
GRILLED CHEESE
10.95
BURGERS
BEEF BURGER
19.95
CHEESEBURGER
21.95
VEGGIE BURGER
16.95
BUFFALO WINGS
21.95
CHICKEN FINGERS
16.95
CHOPPED LIVER (APP)
14.95
GEFILTE FISH
10.95
KNISH SQUARE (FRIED)
7.95
KNISH ROUND (BAKED)
7.95
POTATO PANCAKE (1)
6.95
STUFFED CABBAGE
16.95
BAKED POTATO
7.95
BAKED YAM
8.95
BOILED POTATO
7.95
CANDIED SWEETS
8.95
CORN ON THE COB
7.95
CREAMED SPINACH
9.95
FRENCH FRIES
9.95
FRESH BROCCOLI
7.95
HOME FRIES
8.95
MASHED POTATO
7.95
PEAS AND CARROTS
7.95
SLICED CARROTS
7.95
STRING BEANS
7.95
SWEET PEAS
7.95
SWEET POTATO FRIES
10.95
SIDES
APPLESAUCE (SIDE)
5.95
AVOCADO (SIDE)
4.95
BACON (SIDE)
8.95
BAKED BEANS (SIDE)
9.95
BREAKFAST SAUSAGE (SIDE)
8.95
COLESLAW (SIDE)
6.95
CORNED BEEF HASH (SIDE)
17.95
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (SIDE)
11.95
FRENCH FRIES (SIDE)
9.95
FRIED MUSHROOMS | ONIONS (SIDE)
8.95
FRUIT SALAD (SIDE)
7.95
HOT PEPPERS (SIDE)
7.95
KASHA VARNISHKAS (SIDE)
11.95
MACARONI SALAD (SIDE)
6.95
OLD FASHIONED ONION RINGS (SIDE)
12.95
PICKLED TOMATOES (SIDE)
7.95
POTATO SALAD (SIDE)
6.95
SAUERKRAUT (SIDE)
5.95
STUFFING (SIDE)
8.95
SWEET PEPPERS (SIDE)
7.95
SWEET POTATO FRIES (SIDE)
10.95
TOMATO (SIDE)
2.95
TOSSED GREEN SALAD (SIDE)
9.95
MERCH
T-SHIRT
29.95
MONSTER MUG
15.00
SOUP MUG
25.00
PASTRAMI HAT
45.00
MYO OMELETTE
15.95
BAGEL
3.95
ROLL
3.95
ENGLISH MUFFIN
3.95
SMOKED FISH
NOVA SCOTIA
22.95
DELI DRINKS
BOTTLE OF WATER
2.50
CAN SODA
3.50
COLUMBIAN COFFEE
3.50
DR BROWNS
3.95
FOUNTAIN SODA
3.25
HOT TEA
3.50
ICED COFFEE
4.95
ICED TEA
4.95
JUICE
4.95
ORANGE JUICE
5.95
KREPLACH SOUP
9.95
NOODLE SOUP
9.95
RICE SOUP
9.95
MUSHROOM BARLEY SOUP
9.95
FRENCH ONION
11.95
DRY MATZO BALL
3.95
DRY KREPLACH
3.95
DRY NOODLES
3.95
DELI ITEMS
COTTAGE CHEESE
6.95
CRANBERRY SAUCE
5.95
GEFILTE FISH
5.00
GRAVY
5.95
HERRING FILET
6.00
MATZO (SLICE)
0.75
MUSTARD (1/2LB)
4.00
OLIVES
6.95
PICKLES (QUART)
10.00
RUSSIAN (1/2LB)
4.00
SINGLE BAGEL
1.50
SINGLE ROLL
1.50
CHICKEN SALAD (1/4LB)
4.75
CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER (1/4LB)
4.50
COLE SLAW (1/4LB)
3.00
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (1/4LB)
2.50
EGG SALAD (1/4LB)
4.50
HERRING | CREAM SAUCE (1/4LB)
5.00
KASHA VARNISHKAS (1/4LB)
2.50
MACARONI SALAD (1/4LB)
3.00
NOVA SALMON (1/4LB)
15.00
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (1/4LB)
3.50
POTATO SALAD (1/4LB)
3.00
RUGGELACH (1/4LB)
4.50
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE (1/4LB)
4.00
SHRIMP SALAD (1/4LB)
7.00
TUNA SALAD (1/4LB)
5.00
VEG CREAM CHEESE (1/4LB)
4.00
WHITEFISH SALAD (1/4LB)
8.00
CHICKEN SALAD (1/2LB)
9.50
CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER (1/2LB)
9.00
COLE SLAW (1/2LB)
6.00
EGG BARLEY | MUSHROOMS (1/2LB)
5.00
EGG SALAD (1/2LB)
9.00
HERRING | CREAM SAUCE (1/2LB)
5.00
KASHA VARNISHKAS (1/2LB)
5.00
MACARONI SALAD (1/2LB)
3.00
NOVA SALMON (1/2LB)
30.00
PLAIN CREAM CHEESE (1/2LB)
7.00
POTATO SALAD (1/2LB)
6.00
RUGGELACH (1/2LB)
8.96
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE (1/2LB)
8.00
SHRIMP SALAD (1/2LB)
14.00
TUNA SALAD (1/2LB)
10.00
VEG CREAM CHEESE (1/2LB)
8.00
WHITEFISH SALAD (1/2LB)
8.00
HOLIDAY
HORSERADISH
5.50
MATZO (BOX)
5.95
CREAMY MASHED POTATOES
9.00
POTATO KUGEL
13.95
CREAMED SPINACH
10.00
SALMON FILET
21.95
STRING BEAN ALMONDINE
13.00
SEDER PLATE
25.00
STUFFED CABBAGE (NO RICE)
16.95
SWEDISH MEATBALLS (25)
39.95
CHAROSET
14.00
MATZO STUFFING
16.00
CHOCOLATE COVERED COCONUT MACARO
15.95
COCONUT MACAROON
13.95
COMBO HOT CB & PASTRAMI
35.95
HOT BRISKET PLATTER
32.95
SALAD PLATTERS
SMOKED WHITEFISH SALAD PLATTER
26.95
SHRIMP SALAD PLATTER
26.95
CAKES
APPLE STRUDEL
11.95
CARROT CAKE
10.95
CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE CAKE
10.95
SEVEN LAYER CAKE
10.95
OREO N CREAM CAKE
10.95
COCONUT SNOWBALL
10.95
GERMAN CHOCOLATE
10.95
BLACK AND WHITE MOUSSE SUPREME
10.95
HOMEMADE CHEESECAKES
ORIGINAL NEW YORK CHEESECAKE
10.95
PEANUT BUTTER CHOC CHIP CHEESECA
12.95
STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE
12.95
PIES
A LA MODE
3.00
APPLE PIE
9.95
BANANA CREAM PIE
9.95
KEY LIME PIE
7.95
PECAN PIE
9.95
PUMPKIN PIE (SEASONAL)
9.95
LARGE BLACK AND WHITE COOKIE
4.95
LARGE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
4.95
RUGGELACH (6)
8.95
MARBLE NUT HALVAH
9.95
RICE PUDDING
7.95
FRUIT JELLO
7.95
HOT BRISKET OF BEEF SANDWICH
26.95
TONGUE SANDWICH
28.95
TURKEY PASTRAMI SANDWICH
24.95
BOILED HAM SANDWICH
20.95
CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH
19.95
CHOPPED LIVER SANDWICH
22.95
EGG SALAD SANDWICH
17.95
HARD SALAMI SANDWICH
22.95
LIVERWURST SANDWICH
17.95
ROLLED BEEF SANDWICH
27.95
SALAMI SANDWICH
22.95
SHRIMP SALAD SANDWICH
21.95
TUNA SALAD SANDWICH
18.95
WHITEFISH SALAD SANDWICH
21.95
Menu as captured Sep 3, 2026 · source ↗
We hold 623 venues in New York, NY and could score 353 of them. This one is not among them, so it has no position — not a low one.
There is no score breakdown to show: nothing we read about this venue earned points in any of the four categories, so a bar chart of zeroes would look like a verdict on the kitchen rather than on what it publishes. What we did read is below.
v1.7.4 0.0/100 = sourcing 0.0/50 (named-farm 0 distinct, named-region 0 distinct, attribute 1 distinct [class=graded-spec x0.00], buzzword 0 distinct) + farm partners 0.0/20 (none scored) + registry 0.0/12 (none listed) + press 0.0/18 (capped at 35% of the 0.0-point evidence base).
Buzzwords only. This venue uses sourcing language ("farm-fresh", "locally sourced") but names no farms, regions, or verifiable attributes.
protein
Prime
Attribute“Onions and Melted American Cheese -- 3 HOT OPEN BRISKET -- 31.88 With French Fries and Gravy PATTY MELT -- 22.61 FRENCH DIP -- 32.91 Prime Roast Beef, dipped in au jus on a Club Roll and au jus on the side. SKYSCRAPER: With Horseradish Sauce CHEESESTEAK Shaved Prime Roast”
on the menu · source ↗
Local authority
- 19 Vital Jewish Delis in NYC ↗
Eater NY
Local authority“Sarge's Delicatessen Founded in 1964, this Murray Hill fixture named after a police officer is open every evening till 11 p.m., a rarity these days. Sporting Tiffany-style lamp shades, dimpled naugahyde booths, and hanging salamis, it was closed by a grease fire in 2012 and remained closed until early 2014. The pastrami is fine-grained and mild, and sandwiches arrive extravagan”