Penny
seafood
Shrimp Cocktail
26
Ice Box
45
Oysters / Countnecks / Shrimp / Mussels / Crudo; Ice Box 120; Ice Box 195
Sesame Brioche + Butter
8
Lettuces + Horseradish
17
Summer Vegetables + Anchovy
17
Chilled Corn Soup + Shrimp
22
Sungolds + Yellowfin Conserva
24
Tuna Carpaccio
29
Melon + Snapper
31
Oysters Confit
21
Baked Razor Clams
22
Squid + Marinated Beans
24
Seafood Broken Rice
36
Swordfish + Cabbage
39
Halibut + Tomato
48
1.5 lb Maine Lobster
MP
Menu as captured Sep 3, 2026 · source ↗
Tied with 163 other venues on equal evidence.
We hold 623 venues in New York, NY and could score 353 of them. Positions are counted against those 353.
v1.7.4 8.8/100 = sourcing 0.0/50 (named-farm 0 distinct, named-region 0 distinct, attribute 0 distinct, buzzword 0 distinct) + farm partners 0.0/20 (none scored) + registry 0.0/12 (none listed) + press 8.8/18 (capped at 35% of the 0.0-point evidence base).
Book on Resy ↗link checked Aug 24, 2026
Authority & awards
- MICHELIN Guide 2026: Selected ↗
MICHELIN Guide
Award - The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City in 2025 ↗
The New York Times
National authority“Penny : Seafood, French : $$$ : 90 East 10th Street : East Village, Manhattan : penny-nyc.com : Last reviewed on June 11, 2024 : ★★★ Colin Clark for The New York Times There is every other seafo”
- The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City in 2026 ↗
The New York Times
National authority“Penny | | | | | --- | --- | --- | | Seafood, French | $$$ | Manhattan | Colin Clark for The New York Times The formula is simple. Take the best of the Northeastern seaboard’s catch, treat it with respect, assign a few scrupulous ornaments — bruised whole olives against gossamer panels of tuna, a primally smoky-hot harissa over snugly stuffed s”