Emmy Squared
pizza
Select Beer
$ 5
House Wine
$ 7
Well Cocktails
$ 9
Nothing shaken, nothing stirred
For The Table
$ 13.90
Sriracha Glazed Chicken Wings
Cheesy Garlic Sticks
$ 13.90
Six crispy garlic breadsticks tossed in roasted garlic and pesto. Served with our red sauce
Zia Friessourcing signal
$ 16.75
Seasoned waffle fries, bacon, scallions, hatch chile cheddar queso, green ranch
Make it a regular portion
$ 9.95
BKLYN Mozz Sticks
$ 15.80
Five large, crispy, hand-stretched, mozzarella sticks served with our signature house-made red sauce; Regular $ 10.90
Shareable
$ 14.50
Regular $ 12.50
Shareable
$ 16.80
Regular $ 11.90
Shareable
$ 15.90
Le Big Matt Burgersourcing signal
$ 28
1/2 lb double-stacked grass-fed beef, American cheese, Sammy sauce, greens & pickles, on a toasted pretzel bun with waffle fries
Make It a Single-Stack
$ 25
Single-Stack
$ 14.90
Double-Stack
$ 17.90
Single-Stack
$ 14.90
Double-Stack
$ 17.90
Create Your Own Detroit-Style Pizza
Sixer
$ 2.50
Tenner
$ 3.50
Sixer
$ 18.80
tenner
$ 26.50
Sixer
$ 24.80
Tenner
$ 32.50
Roni Supreme
Tenner
$ 33.50
Sixer
$ 25.80
Mvp
Sixer
$ 20.80
Tenner
$ 29.50
Make it a VIP | add ezzo pepperoni & Calabrian chile $ 5
Vip
Tenner
$ 34.50
Sixer
$ 23.80
Tenner
$ 31.50
Tenner
$ 28.50
Deluxe
Sixer
$ 18.80
Angel
Sixer
$ 23.80
Tenner
$ 32.50
Skillet Baked Brownie
$ 10
warm triple chocolate baked brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and maldon salt
Blue Raspberry Lemonade
Pizza Sticks
$ 10
Chicken Bites
$ 10
Burger
$ 10
Menu as captured Sep 3, 2026 · source ↗
We hold 623 venues in New York, NY and could score 353 of them. Positions are counted against those 353.
v1.7.4 2.2/100 = sourcing 1.7/50 (named-farm 0 distinct, named-region 1 distinct, attribute 1 distinct [class=feed-or-husbandry x0.40], buzzword 0 distinct) + farm partners 0.0/20 (none scored) + registry 0.0/12 (none listed) + press 0.6/18 (capped at 35% of the 1.7-point evidence base).
produce
Hatch chile
Named region“garlic breadsticks tossed in roasted garlic and pesto. Served with our red sauce Zia Fries Seasoned waffle fries, bacon, scallions, hatch chile cheddar queso, green”
on the menu · source ↗
sourcing
grass-fed
Attribute“Big Matt Burger 1/2 lb double-stacked grass-fed beef, American cheese, Sammy sauce, greens & pickles, on a toasted pretzel bun with waffle fries”
on the menu · source ↗
Local authority
- 22 Top Sit-Down Pizzerias in NYC | Eater NY ↗
Eater NY
Local authority“Emmy Squared Co-owners Emily Hyland and Matt Hyland first made waves in the NYC pizza landscape with the thin-crusted pies with interesting toppings (and, of course, that burger) at their first restaurant, Emily, in Clinton Hill. But their finest contribution to the city’s pie repertoire is the Detroit-inspired square pies that first debuted at their second restaurant, Emmy Squ”
Lifestyle coverage
- 11 Best Gluten Free Pizza in NYC All Pizza Lovers Will Enjoy Eating ↗
Time Out New York
National lifestyle“Emmy Squared Pizza Williamsburg price 2 of 4 Recommended Photograph: Courtesy Emmy Squared There's a reason Emmy Squared's spongy Detroit-style squares were awarded four stars by a past Time Out critic. Not only does Emmy Squared give some shine to sharp-edged pies, but the blend of ingredients—like pickled jalapeños and honey or kimchi and sausage—are creative, too. All of Emm”
- The 30 Best Pizza Places in NYC ↗
Thrillist
National lifestyle“Emmy Squared Multiple locations $$$$ Matt and Emily Hyland’s modern pizzeria is dedicated to crisp Detroit-style pies. Emmy Squared and its sister restaurant, Emily, churn out pies that are just as attractive as they are delicious. The Roni Supreme, polka-dotted with pepperoni, plus Calabrian chilis for an extra kick, is a longtime favorite, and the shop also proves they have m”