Bluebeard
Charcuterie & Cheese*
chef’s choice of two types of meat & two kinds of cheese, cornichon, wholegrain mustard, mustardo, amelia’s bread* 24 (*gf)
Grilled Bread
seasonal butters, roasted garlic oil 14 (v/nf)
Pickle Plate
rotating house-made pickles, benedictine 9 (v/gf/nf)
Oysters*
on the half shell, cocktail sauce, mignonette 4/ea (1.50/ea on Sundays) (gf/nf/df)
Farmer Crudité
seasonal raw vegetables from full hand farm, feta tzatziki, cucumber vinegar, sunflower seeds, nutritional yeast 15 (v/gf/nf)
Chips & Dip
house potato chips, avocado ranch 7 (v/gf/nf)
Summer Panzanellasourcing signal
local greens, heirloom tomato, smashed cucumber, house-made mozzarella*, amelia’s bread*, dill, basil, peach white balsamic vinaigrette (vegan*/gf*/df*/nf) 10/18
Grilled Carrots
hazelnut muhamara, pomegranate molasses, hazelnut, feta, bread 19 (gf/cdf/v)
Sides & Soup (General Tso Cauliflower)
tempura battered cauliflower, scallion 14 (v/df/nf)
Patatas Bravas
green tomato salsa, garlic aioli, scallion 13 (v/df/nf)
Green Beans
mustard vinaigrette, pine nut, basil 10 (cnf, df, gf)
Charred cucumber
persian cucumber, house-made goat milk yogurt, chili crisp, lots of cilantro, dill 16 (nf/v/gf)
Grilled Broccolini
tuscan kale, tahini ceasar dressing, pecorino, chive, breadcrumb, lemon zest 16 (cgf/cdf/nf)
Burratasourcing signal
heirloom tomato, local peaches, saba, Amelia’s bread 18 (v/gf*/nf)
Hamachi Crudo*
plum, fresno, pickled beet, tomato ponzu, yuzu oil, shiso, delfino cilantro 24 (df/nf)
Tagliatelle
house-made egg pasta, my dad’s sweet corn, house bacon, black pepper, grana padano, mint 27 (nf/cdf/cv)
Goat Cheese Ravioli
house-made egg pasta, corn, chanterelles, gremolata, grana padano 27 (v/nf)
Bucatini
house-made egg pasta, creamy peperonata ragu, basil oil, breadcrumb 26 (nf/df/cvegan)
Semi-Boneless 1/2 Chicken*
miller amish chicken, chochoyote dumplings, coconut chicken blanquette, pistachio salsa macha, romano beans, delfino cilantro 38 (gf/df)
Smoked Porkchop*
gunthorp farm pork, marinated cherry tomato, celery leaf, tamari butter 45 (nf)
Beef Picanha*
fischer farm’s beef, squash purée, marinated summer squash, green coriander chimichuri 57 (nf/gf/df)
Faroe Island Salmonsourcing signal
zucchini, sweet corn, romano beans, ladolemono, basil, calabrian chili (nf/df/gf) 38
Charcuterie & Cheese*
chef’s choice of two types of meat & two kinds of cheese, cornichon, wholegrain mustard, mustardo, amelia’s bread* 24 (*gf)
Grilled Bread
seasonal butters, roasted garlic oil 14 (v/nf)
Pickle Plate
rotating house-made pickles, benedictine 9 (v/gf/nf)
Oysters*
on the half shell, cocktail sauce, mignonette 4/ea (1.50/ea on Sundays) (gf/nf/df)
Farmer Crudité
seasonal raw vegetables from full hand farm, feta tzatziki, cucumber vinegar, sunflower seeds, nutritional yeast 15 (v/gf/nf)
Chips & Dip
house potato chips, avocado ranch 7 (v/gf/nf)
Summer Panzanellasourcing signal
local greens, heirloom tomato, smashed cucumber, house-made mozzarella*, amelia’s bread*, dill, basil, peach white balsamic vinaigrette (vegan*/gf*/df*/nf) 10/18
Grilled Broccolini
tuscan kale, tahini ceasar dressing, pecorino, chive, breadcrumb, lemon zest 16 (cgf/cdf/nf)
Grilled Carrots
hazelnut muhamara, pomegranate molasses, hazelnut, feta, bread 19 (gf/cdf/v)
Sides & Soup (General Tso Cauliflower)
tempura battered cauliflower, scallion 14 (v/df/nf)
House Fries
kennebec potatoes, remolata, parmesan, ketchup 8 (v/nf)
Melon & Hamsourcing signal
edward’s country ham*, heirloom melon, cherry tomato, red onion, whipped ricotta*, marcona almond*, mint, basil 21 (gf/cv*/cnf*/cdf*)
Burratasourcing signal
heirloom tomato, local peaches, saba, Amelia’s bread 18 (v/gf*/nf)
Hamachi Crudo*
plum, fresno, pickled beet, tomato ponzu, yuzu oil, shiso, delfino cilantro 24 (df/nf)
Salmon Power Bowl*
barley, farro, red cabbage, cucumber, baby kale, chipotle lime vinaigrette*, sesame, pickled carrot 24 (nf/df*)
Spaghetti & Meatballs
pork meatballs, basil, gremolata, tomato sauce, parmesan, garlic bread 18
Pesto Mac
house-made pasta, four cheese sauce, basil pesto, bread crumb, pistachio* 17 (v/nf*)
BLTsourcing signal
bacon, gem lettuce, heirloom tomato, swiss, garlic mayo, amelia’s semolina chips 18 (nf/df*)
Hot Italian
capocollo, ham, finocchiona, mozzarella, shallot, shrettuce, red wine vinaigrette, mayo, banana pepper, sub roll, chips 18 (nf)
Chicken Sando
grilled chicken thigh, basil pesto, mozzarella, bacon, arugula, pickled red onion, sesame bun, chips 17 (nf)
Bluebeard Burger
fischer farm’s beef, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, sesame bun, special sauce, chips 20 (nf)
Steak & Eggs
skirt steak, chimichuri, over easy egg, house fries (gf/nf/cdf) 30
Honeybee
flourless chocolate cake, chocolate mousse, honey drizzle 13 (gf/nf)
Cornbread
financier cake, almond, parmesan créme, lime sweet corn, chili powder 13 (gf)
Pavlova
meringue, local peaches, peach chantilly, sunflower 12 (gf/nf)
guava, strawberry, black tea 12 (gf/df/nf/v) (Chocolate Brûlée)
chocolate mousse, cardamom chantilly, orange confit 13 (v/gf/nf)
Croissant Pudding
amelia’s croissant, hazelnut, caramel sauce, chantilly, feuilletine 12
Opera Cake
almond sponge cake, coffee butter cream, chocolate ganache 13 (gf)
Fig Ice Cream
goat milk, figs, pecan, orange zest 12 (cnf/ gf)
Pistachio Tart
pistachio sponge cake, almond mousse, pistachio, cherries 13 (gf) PLEASE NOTE (***) We do not list all ingredients on the menu. Please alert your server to your allergies and dietary restrictions.
Friday – Saturday | 11am to 11pm (Sunday | 5 to 10pm)
We accept limited reservations, walk-ins always welcome
Menu as captured Sep 1, 2026 · source ↗
We hold 106 venues in Indianapolis, IN and could score 28 of them. Positions are counted against those 28.
v1.7.4 4.0/100 = sourcing 3.1/50 (named-farm 0 distinct, named-region 1 distinct, attribute 1 distinct [class=provenance-adjective x0.50], buzzword 0 distinct) + farm partners 0.0/20 (none scored) + registry 0.0/12 (none listed) + press 0.9/18.
seafood
Faroe Island salmon
Named region“tamari butter 45 (nf) Beef Picanha* fischer farm’s beef, squash purée, marinated summer squash, green coriander chimichuri 57 (nf/gf/df) Faroe Island Salmon zucchini, sweet corn, romano beans, ladolemono, basil, calabrian chili (nf/df/gf) 38 Snacks Charcuterie & Cheese*”
on the menu · source ↗
sourcing
heirloom
Attribute“seeds, nutritional yeast 15 (v/gf/nf) Chips & Dip house potato chips, avocado ranch 7 (v/gf/nf) Summer Panzanella local greens, heirloom tomato, smashed cucumber, house-made mozzarella*, amelia’s bread*, dill, basil, peach white balsamic vinaigrette”
on the menu · source ↗
See the week▾
| Sunday | 5pm – 10pm |
|---|---|
| Monday | lunch 11am – 3pm · lunch 3pm – 5pm · dinner 5pm – 10pm |
| Tuesday | lunch 11am – 3pm · lunch 3pm – 5pm · dinner 5pm – 10pm |
| Wednesday | lunch 11am – 3pm · lunch 3pm – 5pm · dinner 5pm – 10pm |
| Thursday | lunch 11am – 3pm · lunch 3pm – 5pm · dinner 5pm – 10pm |
| Friday | lunch 11am – 3pm · lunch 3pm – 5pm · dinner 5pm – 11pm |
| Saturday | brunch 11am – 3pm · lunch 3pm – 5pm · dinner 5pm – 11pm |
Overlapping time blocks on the page were rejected rather than merged (likely happy-hour/bar hours): monday 11:00-22:00 (overlaps 11:00-15:00); tuesday 11:00-22:00 (overlaps 11:00-15:00); wednesday 11:00-22:00 (overlaps 11:00-15:00); thursday 11:00-22:00 (overlaps 11:00-15:00); friday 11:00-23:00 (overlaps 11:00-15:00); saturday 11:00-23:00 (overlaps 11:00-15:00)
Hours checked Aug 30, 2026 · source ↗ · these hours were read from the page text rather than published schedule data, so we show the week instead of calling it open or closed · Always worth confirming with the restaurant.
Book on the restaurant's own site ↗link checked Aug 30, 2026
Coverage
- eater-indy-38 restaurant guide entry: Bluebeard ↗
eater-indy-38
Press - IM Best Restaurants 2025 entry: Bluebeard ↗
indymonthly-2025
Press